Leadership When the Maps Stop Working
Updated: Nov 4
Wisdom, intuition and leadership when the maps stop working
A couple of weeks ago I talked about a navigation light that is sitting right in front of me as I write this. Sometimes the answers we are looking for are right in front of us. And sometimes they are very much on the horizon. And beyond.
My website has a headline that says, “something has shifted.” It sure has.
I have talked a lot about walks. About silence. About nature and London tubes and boardrooms. About listening, seeing, and discerning. They may appear to be very different subjects. For me, they are connected by a question that has followed much of my work:
How do we know what to pay attention to when there is no obvious answer?
Can Wisdom Be Packaged?
There is a great deal of talk right now about ancient wisdom from the past and how we bring it into the future. It is good stuff, for sure. But can you package and brand such wisdom?
I don't think we can brand wisdom. I don't think we can brand real knowing. I don't think we can brand insight. It is like the Supreme Court ruling. You know it when you see it.
That may sound like an odd thing to say in a world that increasingly wants everything named, categorized, measured, and turned into a methodology.
Frameworks can be useful. Models can be useful. Data is useful. But there are moments in leadership when the framework no longer quite fits what is happening. The map stops working. And yet a decision still has to be made.
What Do Leaders Do When the Maps Stop Working?
I have spent my career in rooms where things were going wrong. Where the maps had stopped working. Where the voice that didn't fit the paradigm turned out to be the one worth listening to. Where saying what I saw, before it could be confirmed, cost something and occasionally changed something.
That kind of decision-making is difficult to reduce to a formula. It asks something different of us. Experience matters. Data matters. Context matters. But so do judgment, discernment, pattern recognition, and the ability to notice what does not quite fit.
Sometimes the most important question in the room is not, What does the data tell us? It is: What are we seeing that the existing model does not know how to explain?
Where Does Real Knowing Come From?
The stories I have been telling here, the navigation light, the empty lots on Lake Winnipesaukee, the walk in Acadia, are not nostalgia. They are where certain knowledge for me actually lives. In the lived experience of those who came before.
And in the evolving resource library in The Commons, I share other sources I have drawn on over the years. Knowledge does not only arrive through formal education, strategy decks, research reports, and executive briefings.
It also arrives through experience. Through conversations, mistakes, observation, and the stories handed to us. And, for me, through the natural world.
What Can Nature Teach Us About Leadership and Systems?
The natural world has always known things about how systems grow, fail, and recover that we are only beginning to name.
For me, this has always been pragmatic. Others may see such thinking as esoteric.
In the time in which we live, I believe those lines are blurred. And for the esoteric-resistant, forgive me for sharing a favored quote of mine which I believe is genuinely applicable today:
“Contact between man and animals and man and the natural world breeds, perhaps — sometimes — wisdom.” — Gregory Bateson, Steps to an Ecology of Mind
Nature is not a leadership framework. That is rather the point. It is a living system.
Forests do not operate through organizational charts. Rivers do not move according to five-year strategic plans. Ecosystems continually respond to disruption, scarcity, abundance, interdependence, competition, and change.
There is something worth noticing there.
Especially for leaders navigating organizations that are themselves complex systems.
Wisdom Only Matters If It Can Meet the Moment
How we draw on all of that, in the moment, with real decisions, is no longer a philosophical conversation. It is a pragmatic one.
Wisdom that cannot meet the moment is of limited use.
The question is how we bring what we know, what we have experienced, what we have inherited, and what we are noticing into the decisions directly in front of us.
A board deciding whether the organization needs to change direction. A CEO sensing that something beneath the numbers is shifting. A leadership team confronting a problem that does not fit the assumptions on which the organization has been built.
These are not abstract conversations when you are sitting in the room. They have consequences.
Why Walking Matters to Me
Walks in nature are indeed pragmatic for me. Walking alongside a client in nature for real conversations about real issues, in the moment and on the horizon, is as well.
There is something about getting out of the room. Out of the slide deck. Out of the pattern in which we have been trying to solve the problem.
Not because nature somehow hands us an answer. But because sometimes changing where we are changes what we are able to see.
Silence can do that too. So can a different question. So can a voice in the room that does not fit the prevailing paradigm.
Connecting the Dots
If we are going to navigate what some would call civilization-changing times, we need to connect these dots. Within ourselves. And in the work we do.
We need data and discernment. Experience and openness. The wisdom inherited from the past and a willingness to recognize that what is emerging may not fit the models we inherited with it.
We need to know when the answer is right in front of us. And when it may still be somewhere beyond the horizon.
There will not always be a framework that tells us which is which. Sometimes we have to see it. Sometimes we have to know it. And sometimes we have to be willing to act before everything can be confirmed.
That is where the work lives.