How Can Leaders See What Others Are Missing?
Updated: Nov 4
There is another story of my grandfather’s that I have been reflecting on since I wrote about his navigation light.
He was trying to convince my father to join his business. They were out on a boat on Lake Winnipesaukee in New Hampshire. Today, it is one of the most sought-after destinations in the region.
At the time, it was anything but. Undeveloped shoreline.
My grandfather, a pragmatic man and, from what I can tell, a visionary man, pointed to the shoreline and told my father, who ultimately chose not to join him, that one day it would be lined with docks and piers.
Great business, he said. He was more than correct. What did he see?
He did not have a spreadsheet projecting the future development of Lake Winnipesaukee. There was no model telling him what would be built there or when.
He read a landscape the way he always did. And he saw what it might become.
Seeing What Others Are Missing
Over the years, I have described my work in various ways. Strategy. Walking alongside leaders. Interim CEO. Linear and nonlinear. None of those descriptions were wrong. But none of them quite said it.
The bulk of my work has been with organizations at a point of transition. Sometimes crisis. Sometimes opportunity. And often, the opportunity resides within the crisis.
A board or leadership team is navigating terrain unknown to them. Something has changed. Perhaps leadership. Perhaps the market. Perhaps the organization itself. Sometimes the systems and structures that worked before simply no longer fit what is emerging.
And often, people are trying to use the same mindset that got them into the problem to find their way out of it.
I see systems. I have always seen systems.
For much of my life, I did not have particularly good language for that. What I could see did not always fit neatly into the prevailing model or the way everyone else in the room was looking at the problem.
Sometimes the ideas arrive early. The room is not yet ready. That does not make them right simply because they are different. But it does mean they are worth examining.
Because leadership requires more than knowing what everyone else already knows.
Why Do Leadership Teams Develop Blind Spots?
There is a voice in most rooms that does not fit the paradigm.
Counter to what the board is seeing and saying. Counter to what the media, however you define that today, is saying. Counter to what the Excel spreadsheet projects.
A still instinct that says: This is not quite right. Or: Over the horizon is something no one else is seeing yet.
Organizations develop ways of seeing the world. They need them. Shared assumptions, systems, language and processes make it possible for people to work together.
But those same things can eventually constrain what an organization is capable of seeing.
The longer we operate inside a system, the easier it becomes to assume that the system itself is reality. It is not. It is one way of organizing reality.
That distinction matters enormously when the environment around the organization begins to change.
At those moments, the question is not merely, What should we do? It may first be: What are we not seeing?
What Role Should Intuition Play in Leadership Decisions?
In 2023, I spent half a day with the poet David Whyte in Oxford. Near the end, he quoted a line from his poem Still Possible: the part of you you thought most foolish is the wisest voice of all.
I raised my hand and asked how one discerns that foolish voice and learns to listen to it and act upon it.
His answer, in essence, was: In silence.
I have walked past that voice myself. More than once. And I have come to understand what it costs when you do.
This does not mean that every instinct is wisdom.
Fear has a voice. Ego has a voice. Bias has a voice. The part of us that desperately wants something to be true has a voice as well.
Leadership requires discernment between them.
But I also think we have spent decades building organizational cultures that privilege what can be quantified while quietly discounting other ways of knowing.
Experience. Context. Pattern recognition. Intuition.
The information held by the people closest to the work. The uncomfortable observation that does not fit the presentation. The person in the room willing to say, “I know the numbers say this, but something does not add up.”
Sometimes that is the beginning of the most important conversation.
Data Matters. But What Is the Spreadsheet Not Showing You?
I am not arguing against data. Data matters. A leader making consequential decisions without good information is taking unnecessary risk. But data and judgment are not the same thing.
An Excel spreadsheet can model what happens if certain assumptions remain true. It cannot tell you whether the assumptions should remain true.
It can show historical patterns. It may be less useful when the pattern itself is changing.
It can tell you what is measurable. That does not mean it contains everything that matters.
Leadership gets particularly difficult when the available information points in several directions at once, or when the decision concerns something that has not happened before.
That is the terrain in which many boards and senior leadership teams find themselves today. There may not be a model for what comes next. There may only be signals. The work is learning how to read them.
Is AI Making Critical Thinking More Important?
Today, with AI, I wonder whether we are becoming too willing to let something else do our thinking. To accept an answer without questioning it. Or to stop looking for what might not be in the answer at all.
AI can synthesize extraordinary amounts of information. It can give us answers faster than most of us imagined possible only a few years ago. But speed and wisdom are not the same thing. Neither are information and judgment.
The danger is not the tool. The danger is allowing the presence of an answer to end the inquiry.
What assumptions sit behind the answer?
What has been omitted?
What happens if the prevailing model is wrong?
What does someone inside the organization know that is not represented in the data?
What possibility has not generated enough evidence to show up yet?
Critical thinking is still a human endeavor. Perhaps it matters more now precisely because answers have become so easy to produce.
Some of the Most Important Signals Come From the Bottom Up
For years, much of my thinking has returned to the difference between top-down and bottom-up systems. Leadership has traditionally been imagined from the top. Information comes upward. Decisions move downward. But organizations are living systems. What happens at the edges matters.
The person closest to the customer may see something before the executive team does. Someone deep within the operation may understand a change long before it appears in a quarterly report. An idea dismissed because of where it originated may eventually become obvious once someone with enough authority repeats it.
The most consequential leverage points in systems are rarely the obvious ones.
This is why listening matters. But it is also why seeing matters.
Leadership is not simply gathering more information from more people. It is recognizing the relationships between things that, on the surface, may not appear related.
That is where patterns emerge. And sometimes they point in a direction the organization has not considered.
What Can Someone Outside the Existing Paradigm See?
In those rooms, I see what I see. Not intentionally. It is just what I do. I do not see around corners. But I do see patterns. Patterns that are not always visible from inside the room.
Sometimes they suggest an entirely different direction, an opportunity not yet considered, or an idea that changes what an organization does next.
Often, they come from the bottom up, not the top down. That is part of what it means for me to walk alongside a leader. It is not simply listening. It is not simply asking a different question. And it is certainly not standing outside the organization and offering a prescription for something I do not fully understand.
It is bringing ideas. Seeing possibilities. Challenging assumptions. Connecting things that may not yet have been connected. And working through decisions that may change the direction of an organization.
Not from outside the room. As part of the thinking inside it.
Leadership Is Not About Seeing Around Corners
My grandfather did not know precisely what would happen on Lake Winnipesaukee. He could not have known every development that would eventually line that shoreline. But he saw something in the landscape. He was willing to name it before it was obvious. That distinction matters.
The work of leadership is not predicting the future with certainty. There is no certainty. It is learning to see the present clearly enough to recognize what might be emerging from it. To pay attention to the signal that does not fit. To listen to the voice we are tempted to dismiss. To question the model when reality no longer behaves according to the model.
And sometimes to point toward an undeveloped shoreline and say: One day.
That is where I do my work.